Counter Offer: Seller's Agent to Buyer's Agent
The seller received an offer $20K below asking. The listing agent needs to send a professional counter offer to the buyer's agent with supporting rationale that justifies the price while keeping the negotiation collaborative.
You are a listing agent drafting a counter offer communication to a buyer's agent. Your tone is professional, data-driven, and collaborative—firm on position but open to creative solutions.
Write a counter offer email from listing agent to buyer's agent with price justification and collaborative tone.
List price: $499K. Offer: $479K. Counter: $492K. Supporting comps: 408 Oak Ridge ($480K, smaller, no kitchen update), 420 Oak Ridge ($495K, similar size, older kitchen), 425 Oak Ridge ($491K, similar but smaller lot). Seller's home advantage: 2023 kitchen renovation, largest lot on street (0.3 acres). Seller willing to be flexible on closing date and include washer/dryer.
Lead with appreciation for the offer. Present the counter with comp data. Highlight the property's advantages over comps. Offer non-price flexibility to signal willingness to negotiate. Keep the door open. Under 150 words. Professional, not adversarial.
You are a listing agent countering an offer to the buyer's agent. Counter at $492K with rationale and collaborative tone. List: $499K. Offer: $479K. Counter: $492K. Comps: $480K (smaller/no kitchen update), $495K (older kitchen), $491K (smaller lot). Seller advantage: 2023 kitchen, largest lot. Flexible on closing, include W/D. Constraints: Appreciate offer. Counter with comp data. Highlight advantages. Offer non-price flex. Keep door open. Under 150 words.
Hi Sarah—thanks for the offer on 412 Oak Ridge. My sellers are pleased with the interest and want to keep this moving forward. They're countering at $492,000. Here's the supporting context: Three Oak Ridge sales in the last 90 days: - 408: $480K (smaller, no kitchen update) - 420: $495K (similar size, older kitchen) - 425: $491K (comparable but smaller lot at 0.22 acres) My clients' home has the 2023 kitchen renovation and the largest lot on the street (0.3 acres), which positions it at or above the $491-495K comp range. Beyond the number: my sellers are flexible on closing timeline and will include the washer/dryer. If there are non-price terms that matter to your buyers, I'm open to a conversation about creative ways to bridge the gap. What are your thoughts?
Why It Works
The comp data gives the buyer's agent ammunition to present the counter to their clients—which is what actually moves negotiations forward. Offering non-price flexibility signals willingness to negotiate without moving on price. The collaborative close ('What are your thoughts?') invites dialogue rather than a take-it-or-leave-it response.